Sovereignty

From the Economist:

"IT WOULD only take half an hour for the French boats and French helicopters to reach the disaster area." Those were the wistful words uttered by Bernard Kouchner, France's foreign minister, as his country's diplomats at the United Nations vainly argued that aid might have to be "imposed" on Myanmar if the military regime refused to co-operate.

Even as he spoke, diplomats from China, Vietnam, South Africa and Russia were mocking his idea that the "responsibility to protect" (a new concept in global affairs, implying that saving human lives might in some extreme circumstances override sovereignty) could be invoked in the case of Myanmar's cyclone. China noted acidly that the idea had not been cited in 2003 when France suffered a deadly heatwave.

So, the French arguement is that the government of Myanmar does not have the ability to sufficiently protect their citizens AND since the government is not popular or democratic, so forced intervention should be allowed.  Seems pretty darn dangerous. . . though with the Chinese/Russian veto no one's forcing themselves into Myanmar.

I'm not suggesting that this should have been done, but President G. W. Bush's government was not popular at the time that Hurricane Katrina hit and they were doing a piss poor job in disaster relief.  Seems to be pretty similar circumstances (though the US President was elected democratically. . .right?).

1 Comment

Leave a comment

Recent Entries

  • That time of the baseball season?

    The last time I thought of the end of the baseball season in these terms were when the Mariners picked up Alex Rodriguez.  Now there's...

  • No More Sonics. . .for now

    The Sonics are leaving. I'm happy that there won't be two lameduck seasons. About the possiblity of the Soncis being in Seattle again, I'm not...

  • Less for More

    Part of the anti-Obama as POTUS plans seem to be to paint him as arrogant or a elitst. "He continues to have a style that...

  • Celtics win in Six

    Midtown court Originally uploaded by angrydicemoose The Celtics won game six to take the finals from the Lakers 4-2. While I don't particularly care...

  • NBA fixes Playoffs?

    I always said that the Sonics lost to the Suns in the 1993 Western Conference Finals because the NBA wanted to see Barkley play Jordan...

Close